RSS Feed

Fee Tail : Jane Austin and Utility of the Law School Property Class

“Mr. Bennet’s property consisted almost entirely in an estate of two thousand a year, which, unfortunately for his daughters, was entailed, in default of heirs male, on a distant relation….. ” – Jane Austin, Pride and Prejudice, Chapter 7.

This odd statement of inheritance is key to understanding the monumental task, and indeed panic, the mother faced in trying to marry off five girls with no income and no dowry. Their charm and their looks are their only currency in a time in which it’s not what you are, but who you are. To explain:

I have not heard the term fee tail since my law school property class. Law school property classes is torture: unlike any other beast of law school terror, this is a mind numbing jaunt back to the time of William the Conquerer, full of archaic languages, meanings, estates and devices. In short, a fee is the way you hold property. In the American system, you typically have fee simple – meaning you just own the property – leases, and sometimes life estates. There are some other odd ones, but for the purposes of normal people this will do. If you buy a house, that is a fee simple. If you inherit property, typically the will gifts from Aunt Auntie Annie to Billy Bob in fee simple. But, in the Old Dominion, if you were special you left your property to the “heirs of my body” in “fee tail.” This is the legacy creation, that your heirs could not sell (and consequently mortgage), gift, or place the property in their own will, or otherwise break up the estate to raise cash or for any other purpose. When one generation of landholders passes, the entire estate goes not to the heirs of the holder, but automatically to the next heir of the original grantor. Confused? Good. Relevant here is that because it was entailed in favor of males, by having five girls, upon father’s death the estate automatically went to the next male heir with nothing to the girl children or the mother. They were out on their tails! (Fee Tail!)

So this is the plot device that matters, because Mrs. Bennet is in a panic to marry the girls off within their social class, a monumental task with five young women, no dowry, and only their good looks as class currency. As Austin let’s us know, their names and reputations aren’t that great. Mrs. Bennet is perpetually worried that Mr. Bennet will pass, which considering actuarial tables of the time, he is as good as dead.

This is important because when the dreadful Mr. Collins comes to pay suit, he is the next heir in line. Upon Mr. Bennet passing, and I mean the day of and not the day of burial, the home in which the Bennet girls reside and their mother will be his. By courting Elizabeth, he is offering to take care of the female side of the family and if they have a son, he will inherit the Longbourne estate. But when Elizabeth rejects Collins’ suit, he rejects the family, and marries Charlotte instead. As Ms. Bennet presumably is past the point of bearing children, the Bennet women are now disinherited completely from the Longbourne estate, which having male grand children will not change afterwards. At this point in the novel, there are no other offers of marriage to any of the young women, and Mr. Darcy is a future fairy-tale. When Elizabeth rejects Mr. Collins, she rejects the best thing that realistically (not fairy tale) the story could offer her. Fortunately for her, this is a work of fiction and the man she loves ditches the heiress and centuries of pomp and circumstance for her. More realistically? An offer to be his mistress and a fallen woman. But all is well that ends well.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: